| Past Grand Worthy Matron | Term | Past Grand Worthy Patron | Term | |
| Margaret A. Teister of Crawfordsville | 1888 – 1891 | Henry Rogan of Indianapolis | 1886 – 1897 | |
| Mary E. Mayzeek of Terre Haute | 1891 – 1894 | Henry Rogan of Indianapolis | 1886 – 1897 | |
| Mary E. Cruitup of Terre Haute | 1884 – 1897 | Henry Rogan of Indianapolis | 1886 – 1897 | |
| Ellen Richman of New Albany | 1897 – 1899 | William F. Tiester of Crawfordsville | 1897 – 1899 | |
| Lucy McFarland of Evansville | 1899 – 1901 | Robert A. Brown of Terre Haute | 1899 – 1903 | |
| Fannie Lanier of Indianapolis | 1901 – 1903 | |||
| Nellie M. Strong of New Castle | 1903 – 1905 | William Anderson of Lafayette | 1903 – 1905 | |
| Rhoda K. Jones of Fort Wayne | 1905 – 1907 | Fred O. Blake of Terre Haute | 1905 – 1906 | |
| Jennie L. Lewis of Indianapolis | 1907 – 1909 | William McFarland of Evansville | 1906 – 1908 | |
| Ida M. Harris of Terre Haute | 1909 – 1911 | Walter H. Russell of Wabash | 1908 – 1911 | |
| Sarah Hale of Crawfordsville | 1911 – 1912 | George W. Strong of New Castle | 1911 – 1917 | |
| Gertrude B. Hill of Indianapolis | 1912 – 1918 | Edward I. Jones of Fort Wayne | 1917 – 1919 | |
| Medora A. Powell of Mishawaka | 1918 – 1921 | William F. Anderson of Lafayette | 1919 – 1921 | |
| Mamie J. Russell of Wabash | 1921 – 1924 | Schyler Goings of Muncie | 1921 – 1923 | |
| Anna M. Ashworth of Terre Haute | 1924 – 1926 | John C. Dawson of Indianapolis | 1923 – 1926 | |
| Bettie D. Wilkes of Indianapolis | 1926 – 1929 | A. F. Kimbrough of New Castle | 1926 – 1929 | |
| Carrie Hockaday of Gary | 1929 – 1932 | Harry Edmonds of Mitchell | 1929 – 1932 | |
| Maude B. Herring of Crawfordsville | 1932 – 1940 | James W. Lewis of Gary | 1932 – 1939 | |
| Johnnie Franklin of Terre Haute | 1940 – 1944 | Lyman Brown of Bloomington | 1939 – 1942 | |
| Golda H. Jones of Fort Wayne | 1944 – 1946 | Thomas Maury of Indianapolis | 1942 – 1945 | |
| Edna J. Morris of Gary | 1946 – 1948 | Albert Hawkins of Marion | 1945 – 1947 | |
| Willa Owsley of Indianapolis | 1948 – 1950 | James Rindy of Fort Wayne | 1947 – 1949 | |
| K. Asenath Burden of Marion | 1950 – 1952 | C. Stircle Patterson of Richmond | 1949 – 1951 | |
| Mattie Anderson of Indianapolis | 1952 – 1954 | John W. Lyda of Terre Haute | 1951 – 1953 | |
| Adelle Starkey of Fort Wayne | 1954 – 1956 | William A. Powell of Princeton | 1953 – 1955 | |
| Rochelle McLemore of Gary | 1956 – 1958 | Milton Jeffries of Marion | 1955 – 1957 | |
| Opal Pettiford of Terre Haute | 1958 – 1961 | Charles Phillips of Gary | 1957 – 1959 | |
| Zeretta Ware of Muncie | 1960 – Honorary | W. Frances Daniels of Richmond | 1959 – 1961 | |
| Elizabeth Phillips of New Albany | 1961 | G. H. Gayhart of Indianapolis | 1961 – 1962 | |
| Evelyn Davis of East Chicago | 1962 – 1964 | Loys Hubbard of Gary | 1962 – 1964 | |
| Mae Carter of New Castle | 1964 – 1966 | Gerald Smith of Indianapolis | 1965 | |
| Doris Garner of South Bend | 1966 – 1968 | Claude Mayberry of Hammond | 1966 – 1968 | |
| Irene Brookins of Indianapolis | 1968 – 1970 | Bowman Metcalfe of Indianapolis | 1968 – 1970 | |
| Anna L. Simmons of Gary | 1970 – 1972 | Oliver B. Forte of Indianapolis | 1970 – 1972 | |
| Alice Thompson of Columbus | 1972 – 1974 | Owen Garner of South Bend | 1972 – 1974 | |
| Annie L. Harris of South Bend | 1974 – 1976 | Henry Kendrick of Gary | 1974 – 1976 | |
| Inez Ingram of Columbus | 1976 – 1978 | John Scott of Evansville | 1976 – 1978 | |
| Betty Hammond of Gary | 1978 – 1980 | Eckler Brooks of Terre Haute | 1978 – 1980 | |
| Karyellen Dunn of Indianapolis | 1980 – 1982 | John Winters, Jr. of Indianapolis | 1980 – 1982 | |
| Ollie Carpenter of Hammond | 1982 | Robert Anderson of Indianapolis | 1982 – 1984 | |
| Cornelius Shambry of South Bend | 1983 – 1985 | William T. Moody of Evansville | 1984 – 1985 | |
| Jane A. Ware of Connersville | 1985 – 1987 | Andrew W. Murray of Indianapolis | 1985 – 1987 | |
| Claudette Johnson of Marion | 1987 – 1989 | Curtis D. Ware of Connersville | 1987 – 1989 | |
| Lena Brooks of Terre Haute | 1989 – 1991 | Oscar C. Smith of Indianapolis | 1989 – 1991 | |
| Helen Anderson of Indianapolis | 1991 – 1993 | Eugene J. Barnett of Fort Wayne | 1991 – 1993 | |
| Delores A. Douglas of Indianapolis | 1993 – 1995 | James H. Douglas, Sr. of Indianapolis | 1993 – 1995 | |
| Beatrice Joiner of Gary | 1995 – 1997 | Lawrence Patterson of Indianapolis | 1995 – 1997 | |
| Diane Thompson of Indianapolis | 1997 – 1999 | Charles Albert of Indianapolis | 1997 – 1999 | |
| Edna P. Rowley of Indianapolis | 1999 – 2001 | James Robison of South Bend | 1999 – 2001 | |
| Valda A. Lewis of East Chicago | 2001 – 2003 | Lucion O’Banion of Indianapolis | 2001 – 2003 | |
| Melody Moore of Anderson | 2003 – 2005 | Bruce E. Wright of Indianapolis | 2003 – 2005 | |
| Phyllis A. Tyler of Indianapolis | 2005 – 2007 | James Andrews of Indianapolis | 2005 – 2007 | |
| Debra A. Merriwether of Indianapolis | 2007-2009 | James H. Woodard, Sr. of Indianapolis | 2007-2009 | |
| Melinda R. Evans of Indianapolis | 2009 – 2011 | John H. Richmond, Sr. of East Chicago | 2009 – 2011 | |
| Gloria Sanders of Gary | 2011 – 2013 | Willie B. Wilson, Jr. of Indianapolis | 2011 – 2013 | |
| Mary A. Lewis of Anderson | 2013 – 2015 | William (Bill) Robinson of Gary | 2013 – 2015 | |
| Loretta Morton of Indianapolis | 2015 – 2017 | Rev. Richard Hunter of Indianapolis | 2015 – 2017 | |
| Barbara A. Reynolds of Indianapolis | 2017 – 2019 | Robert Apple of Indianapolis | 2017 – 2019 | |
| Elain Jewell James of Indianapolis | 2019-2021 | Larry Brown of Indianapolis | 2019-2021 | |
| Dr Dea L. Bell of Muncie | 2021-2023 | Shawn Pitts of Indianapolis | 2021-2022 | |
| Dr Martin F Hill of Indianapolis | 2022-2023 | |||
| Walter Turner of Gary | 2023-2024 |